HP6 and what my pangga has to say
my pangga tried to start a blog of his own.. just to get a feel of why i was into it.. he had i think 3 posts and one of them is this..
i just thought i'll place it here para may kakwentuhan kami.. hahaha.. and si lei.. =)
this is about HP6 by the way.. so if you havent read the book yet.. might as well STOP here.. =D
~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~
The only book I was able to bring was my latest one, HP6. So that's what I read over and over again. I think I'm on my 5th or 6th pass already. My pangga asks me why I always re-read the thing and not just get another book from my sister's shelf. What can I say? I like the thing, hence my url and title. And I'm trying to find some proof to support or discredit my theory on why things happened and what probably would happen on the HP7. So far, my theory is holding out. My theory is this: Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him. Want proof?
Fact # 1, Hagrid overheard Dumbledore and Snape arguing in the forest - I suspect this is where Dumbledore asked Snape.
Fact # 2, Dumbledore injured his arm and Snape was the only one he approached to cure it. Snape is the only one along with Dumbledore who knows his true condition. Dumbledore might already be dying and they can't do a thing to stop it, so why not use it in their advantage?
Fact # 3, the death eaters are suspecting snape's loyalty. Killing Dumbledore would defenitely help them convince that he is on their side which brings back Dumbledore to creating "the plan".
Fact # 4, Dumbledore knows Draco's task and he did not even attempt to accost or comfront Draco since he knows Draco's predicament. This might be another possible good reason to sacrifice his life, to save Draco and his family.
Fact # 5, Dumbledore keeps asking Harry to look for Snape when they get back, why? Possibly to act on "the plan"
~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~
posted by jane @ 11/21/2005 09:59:00 AM
9 Comments:
ok sa mga conspiracy theories ah hehe. made me think about it also... i remember dumbledore saying the word "please" to snape before snape killed him. maybe that was to encourage snape??
Hehe ... I was going to put the same thing Lei put. Maybe Dumbledore knows about the "Unbreakable Vow" Snape made with Draco's mom (I forget her name). So, he knows Snape will really have to kill him. The "please" was put there to confuse us. But in actuality, it's Dumbledore pleading to Snape to go along with the plan. It's "Severus, please kill me." Not "Severus, please don't kill me."
ehehe, yup, isa din yun sa mga points na nde ko nalagay ... and maybe that's why snape is so furious because he thinks that dumbledore is asking him to kill him and is taking "things for granted" ...
hey oneal, anong blog name mo? pabasa naman! hehehe!
oo nga oneal, may blog ka na ... bakit di sya public?
wow, mukhang bumenta yung theory ko ah =) pero I promise you, there's not much to see on my blog site ... but if you still would like to take a peek, eto yung url ko ...
http://dumbledorespensive.blogspot.com/
-- o'neal
how about this... both of you guys blog about the same stuff, then give different comments or insights about the incident?
sort of he said, she said. hehehe!
i could never get alfredo to blog. he just sneaks around other people's blog. hehehe!
I haven't re-read HP6 at all. Hehe. As soon as I was done with it, people just took it from me and never returned it. :-(
Anywho, I talked about this to a friend of mine and he said that in reading the "Unbreakable Vow" chapter, he found it interesting that Snape didn't seem to know what Narcissa Malfoy was talking about. Like, he was trying to fish something out from Narcissa because he didn't know any of Voldemort's plans.
I haven't read the book, so I don't know how true this is. But since O'neal had read it for 6 times, I'd like to hear his two cents. :-) So, whatcha think O'neal?
hmmm, yeah, that might be true ... this fits because Snape was so interested in knowing what Narcissa was talking about ... which also supports the theory that Voldemort's side already suspects Snape's loyalty ....
Post a Comment
<< Home